Performance limits of the three MEMS inertial energy generator transduction types

In this paper, trends from the last 10 years of inertial micro-generator literature are investigated and it is shown that, although current generator designs are still operating well below their maximum power, there has been a significant improvement with time. Whilst no clear conclusions could be drawn from reported fabricated devices with respect to preferred transducer technology, this paper presents operating charts for inertial micro-generators which identify optimal operating modes for different frequencies and normalized generator sizes, and allows comparison of the different transduction mechanisms as these parameters vary. It is shown that piezoelectric generators have a wider operating range at low frequency than electromagnetic generators, but as generator dimensions increase, the frequency to which piezoelectric transducers outperform electromagnetic transducers decreases. (Some figures in this article are in colour only in the electronic version)